No thanks on Les Miles. As for Richt... If RR left and we ended up with him, I would be neither ecstatic or distraught; I might be a little more hopeful.AZarchery wrote:Lol yeah they beat us but have they competed for a pac 12 title year in and year out like Stanford (Stanford has good recruiting classes but not great recruiting classes)? Have they made it to the college football playoff with their fantastic recruiting classes? Nope. Why? Because COACHING matters more than recruiting. And we have one of the best damn COACHES there is. Look how much production we have gotten out of 0 nfl talent. Personally I would rather have rich rod around for a long a time, because he will eventually get that one or two recruiting classes he needs to break through. Or would you rather have mark richt and les miles? Hoards of nfl talent every year yet never really doing anything with it. And before you say "well I want both." This is Arizona. We have no tradition, no money, and not much in state talent. You can't just hire some up and coming d coordinator and "get both."Merkin wrote:Beat Arizona?AZarchery wrote: It's that easy huh? Just recruit better and that will solve all the problems? USC and UCLA seem to kill us in the recruiting trail every year and what have they done recently?
I remember when people wanted Sean Miller fired because "he had too many transfers" and "he didn't make it to the tournament one year." That's what everyone complains about rich rod sounds like. Everyone seems to think we can just fire rich rod and replace him with someone better, which is a total unknown. Patience.
As for no money and no in-state talent... That is a pretty big overstatement, I believe RR has the 3rd highest salary among P12 FB coaches... and I would say Arizona is consistently producing more in state talent than any state in the P12 region behind California (although we trail them by a VERY wide margin and always will).
As for the comparison to Miller... That is utter horseshit. The idiots who complained about him after season 3 were completely out to lunch. He had a couple tough seasons that were completely understandable (1&3), but his coaching success over his entire career is indisputable... The program trajectory was never in question... and it was crystal clear that significantly better days lied immediately ahead. If you think that is where we sit with our FB program today, we agree to disagree.
You are dead right that we cannot just fire RR and immediately replace him with someone better. Which is why a vast majority of even the most disgruntled are NOT calling for Rich Rod's ouster.