I think its tough to say my post was riddled with Confirmation bias. I will be honest and say I have met Miller twice and was not really that impressed either time. I might be biased because of that as he honestly was kind of a dick. I had been fortunate to meet Lute a couple times too and literally was like meeting the Pope. He is just an unreal class act. But I also met Rich Rod and thought he was cool so what do I know!azcat34 wrote:Newport's post is riddled with confirmation bias.
Sean Miller was the head coach at Xavier taking over a program that has historically performed well.
Xavier was an independent until 1979 and until that point had made the NCAA Tournament once (1961) and NIT once (1959).
Then was in the Midwestern Collegiate Conference until 1995 -- hardly a conference for basketball prowess.
Skip Prosser and Thad Matta are certainly accomplished coaches, but when Miller took over Xavier as a basketball program had made the second weekend twice -- and they have been playing basketball since the 1920's.
Miller had a down 17-12 season after Matta left, but then proceeded to have two trips to the second weekend of his own in his final four seasons at Xavier.
This also included Xavier's second round loss to the Conley and Oden Ohio State team that was one in my personal opinion one of the best NCAA tournament games I had ever seen. Here is a refresher:
Point is, Miller's accomplishments at Xavier were extremely impressive. That combined with being a Jamelle Horne shot, a Nick Johnson shot and a 3-point shooting barrage by Wisconsin that was completely undefendable from making a Final Four at Arizona is pretty damn impressive.
Wichita State loss sucked, Buffalo loss really sucked -- but Miller has still made the second weekend five times in nine years Arizona. Let's not forget that our program was nothing short of a dumpster fire that the Andy Katz's of the world thought would take five years just to rebuild. Miller's 16-15 season is probably one of his most impressive considering what team he had in place when he took the job in 2009.
Lute was an excellent coach and a visionary for seeing the potential Arizona had, but Miller is a more than worthy successor.
Arizona isn't the only school caught up in this scandal and when all the evidence from the FBI gets out there will be many more.
Arizona is extremely lucky to have a coach like Miller and it is disappointing to see so many posters on this site do a total 180 on him after an admittedly terrible end to this season. The vast majority of schools around the country would love to have him.
In terms of Xavier, I went back and looked and honestly, it was actually stronger then I thought before Miller took over. Since 1985, the program has won less then 20 games, 5 times. Had a losing season once. Been to the NCAA Tournament 25 times out of 31 years. Won 17 conference titles. I didn't realize how well Pete Gillen did there too from 85-94.
Maybe Historically was a strong word but since 1985 they have been a legit program considering how small their school is. I honestly think you have the confirmation bias to make Miller look better.
Since he has left, he has taken Arizona to the 2nd weekend, 5 times as you mentioned. Chris Mack has taken Xavier there 4 times. Thad Matta had a better winning percentage then Miller in his three years there that was right before Miller took over.
I think you can tell whether someone is a great coach or were at a Great program by the success that happens after they leave. I think really difficult to say they have missed a beat with Chris Mack at the throne. And Millers accomplishments at Xavier were no doubt good but I think saying extremely impressive shows major confirmation bias. I think its obvious that Xavier is a great program and it was not all Sean Miller like I view with Lute and Arizona. Lute built and created Arizona out of nothing.
I would also disagree that the vast majority of schools around the country would love to have him. Right now and for the foresable future, the vast majority of schools would not touch Miller. I think his brand has been tainted really badly. Zero chance a marquee program like UNC comes calling for him until his name his cleared and he makes a couple Final Four runs. Again, I think the ESPN story was bullshit in terms of him talking to Dawkins about paying Deandre but we live in times of guilty until proven innocent.
Maybe my expectations for our program are too high but I think saying I have confirmation bias about Miller's time at Xavier is just incorrect. Facts do not support that