Nico Mannion
Moderators: UAdevil, JMarkJohns
- Longhorned
- Posts: 14758
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 1:04 pm
- Reputation: 975
- Location: In a guayabera at The Sands Club, Arizona Stadium
Re: Nico Mannion
Bayless could take over a game. He was a killer. Mannion isn’t remotely in the conversation when you talk about Bayless. Mannion has curly hair and supposedly can play in the NBA, according to some kind of mental experiment that doesn’t correlate to what he can show in an actual game of college basketball. That’s all I can give him.
Re: Nico Mannion
This was one of my biggest frustrations with Mannion. He should have been the best player on the court in all of our games. I kept waiting for him to take over and carry the team. Instead I got a lot of 26 footersLonghorned wrote:Bayless could take over a game. He was a killer. Mannion isn’t remotely in the conversation when you talk about Bayless. Mannion has curly hair and supposedly can play in the NBA, according to some kind of mental experiment that doesn’t correlate to what he can show in an actual game of college basketball. That’s all I can give him.
I thought his game winner in Anaheim was going to be the start of something special. Oh well. I will root for him to succeed in the league
-
- Posts: 3490
- Joined: Sat Sep 23, 2017 3:25 pm
- Reputation: 340
Re: Nico Mannion
Curious if he ever fully healed/recovered from that injury early in season.
He had 24’ range this last season.
Not sure how many shots were even as close as 26’.
I really think his shot selection (distance) hurt his game.
He had 24’ range this last season.
Not sure how many shots were even as close as 26’.
I really think his shot selection (distance) hurt his game.
Re: Nico Mannion
i think his poor shooting hurt his game
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Nico is way too athletic to settle for 26 footers, especially *contested* 26 footers. Watching him this past season, it just seemed he hasn't figured out how to be a high impact PG yet. If he'd averaged closer to 10 APG (he was just over 5) and took fewer shots, we might've added a few wins, imo.
- Merkin
- Posts: 43386
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1581
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: Nico Mannion
The way his shots were coming up short and how he trotted down the court it sure like he didn't have any legs left end of season, but could have been a conditioning issue. Which is odd for someone who plays endless AAU games.Postmaster wrote:Curious if he ever fully healed/recovered from that injury early in season.
He had 24’ range this last season.
Not sure how many shots were even as close as 26’.
I really think his shot selection (distance) hurt his game.
But he is still a teen and actually had to play defense for once in his life.
Re: Nico Mannion
35.7mpg - 45.8%fg - 40.7%3pt - 83.9%ft - 4apg - 2.7rpg - 1spg - 19.7ppg
Re: Nico Mannion
As the stats (given by 97) and actually watching the games showed, Jerryd Bayless was a much better player than Nico. Bayless had a decent career as a backup in the NBA, got to figure a backup is Nico's NBA ceiling. I'm hoping he proves me wrong though.97cats wrote:35.7mpg - 45.8%fg - 40.7%3pt - 83.9%ft - 4apg - 2.7rpg - 1spg - 19.7ppg
Re: Nico Mannion
32.2mpg - 39.2%fg - 32.7%3pt - 79.7%ft - 5.3apg - 2.5rpg - 1.2spg - 14ppg
-
- Posts: 1736
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:01 pm
- Reputation: 341
Re: Nico Mannion
A good comp for Nico Mannion is Jordan Farmar, he was able to hang around the league on and off for a decade.
Jordan Farmar actually stayed his Sophomore year and took UCLA to the finals, Would have been nice to get the same from Nico before he bounced.
Jordan Farmar actually stayed his Sophomore year and took UCLA to the finals, Would have been nice to get the same from Nico before he bounced.
Last edited by gronk4heisman on Mon Apr 27, 2020 3:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13841
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2885
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: Nico Mannion
That game winning shot was nothing but luck. It was an ugly, ugly shot.Frybry02 wrote:Longhorned wrote: I thought his game winner in Anaheim was going to be the start of something special. Oh well. I will root for him to succeed in the league
I would argue that that shot actually made him think he was a good shooter on this level and led to his piss poor shot selection.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Yeah, it's possible my memory sucks, but I remember Farmar making a MUCH bigger splash for UCLA than Nico did for us. It could be that he played that second year, but even as a freshman (wasn't that Howland's first year?) he was already pretty solid.gronk4heisman wrote:A good comp for Nico Mannion is Jordan Farmar, he was able to hang around the league on and off for a decade.
Jordan Farmar actually stayed his Sophomore year and took UCLA to the finals, Would have been nice to get the same from Nico before he bounced.
-
- Posts: 1736
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:01 pm
- Reputation: 341
Re: Nico Mannion
From 97's metrics, below is Nico:Beachcat97 wrote:Yeah, it's possible my memory sucks, but I remember Farmar making a MUCH bigger splash for UCLA than Nico did for us. It could be that he played that second year, but even as a freshman (wasn't that Howland's first year?) he was already pretty solid.gronk4heisman wrote:A good comp for Nico Mannion is Jordan Farmar, he was able to hang around the league on and off for a decade.
Jordan Farmar actually stayed his Sophomore year and took UCLA to the finals, Would have been nice to get the same from Nico before he bounced.
32.2mpg - 39.2%fg - 32.7%3pt - 79.7%ft - 5.3apg - 2.5rpg - 1.2spg - 14ppg
Farmar freshman stats
34.4mpg - 41.1%fg - 33.3%3Pt - 80.1%ft - 5.3apg - 3.5rpg - 1.4spg - 13.2ppg
Almost identical numbers, maybe it felt bigger because of their improvement from the prior years (Howlands first and Lavins last were pretty bad).
Re: Nico Mannion
For comparison, these were my numbers in college:
00.0 mpg - 00.0%fg - 00.0%3pt - 00.0%ft - 0.0 apg - 0.0 rpg - 0.0 spg - 00 ppg
00.0 mpg - 00.0%fg - 00.0%3pt - 00.0%ft - 0.0 apg - 0.0 rpg - 0.0 spg - 00 ppg
Re: Nico Mannion
you never missed a shot in college!azgreg wrote:For comparison, these were my numbers in college:
00.0 mpg - 00.0%fg - 00.0%3pt - 00.0%ft - 0.0 apg - 0.0 rpg - 0.0 spg - 00 ppg
i was going to put the ua/asu records here...but i forgot what they were.
i'll just go with fuck asu.
i'll just go with fuck asu.
- Longhorned
- Posts: 14758
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 1:04 pm
- Reputation: 975
- Location: In a guayabera at The Sands Club, Arizona Stadium
Re: Nico Mannion
There have been some Washington State teams that wouldn't have finished too many games ahead of a team of 12 of us in the conference standings.
-
- Posts: 1819
- Joined: Mon Jun 09, 2014 3:40 pm
- Reputation: 82
Re: Nico Mannion
What exactly indicates to you that Nico is athletic?Beachcat97 wrote:Nico is way too athletic to settle for 26 footers, especially *contested* 26 footers. Watching him this past season, it just seemed he hasn't figured out how to be a high impact PG yet. If he'd averaged closer to 10 APG (he was just over 5) and took fewer shots, we might've added a few wins, imo.
He's going to get torched by the modern NBA PG.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Nico is athletic enough to get into the lane, create shots and often get to the basket...at the NCAA level. We barely saw a glimmer of his college potential, and now he's gonzo. I agree: he's underprepared for the NBA and will most likely not stick. It's a shame.legallykenny wrote:What exactly indicates to you that Nico is athletic?Beachcat97 wrote:Nico is way too athletic to settle for 26 footers, especially *contested* 26 footers. Watching him this past season, it just seemed he hasn't figured out how to be a high impact PG yet. If he'd averaged closer to 10 APG (he was just over 5) and took fewer shots, we might've added a few wins, imo.
He's going to get torched by the modern NBA PG.
-
- Posts: 2637
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2014 2:35 pm
- Reputation: 432
Re: Nico Mannion
He basically stopped going to the lane because he wasn't physically mature/ready yet.Beachcat97 wrote:Nico is athletic enough to get into the lane, create shots and often get to the basket...at the NCAA level. We barely saw a glimmer of his college potential, and now he's gonzo. I agree: he's underprepared for the NBA and will most likely not stick. It's a shame.legallykenny wrote:What exactly indicates to you that Nico is athletic?Beachcat97 wrote:Nico is way too athletic to settle for 26 footers, especially *contested* 26 footers. Watching him this past season, it just seemed he hasn't figured out how to be a high impact PG yet. If he'd averaged closer to 10 APG (he was just over 5) and took fewer shots, we might've added a few wins, imo.
He's going to get torched by the modern NBA PG.
He only did floaters and chucked a bunch of outside shots.
Imho he wasn't really ready physically for the college level let alone the NBA.
Re: Nico Mannion
https://bleacherreport.com/articles/288 ... aft-boards" target="_blank
Nico Mannion, PG, Arizona
A recent scan of the mock draft universe found that Nico Mannion's draft range stretches from No. 10 to No. 30.
NBC Sports' Rob Dauster came in on the higher end, projecting the 19-year-old to go 14th overall, but the subsequent write-up was far from flattering:
"My concern with drafting him this high is that he doesn't really have an NBA skill. He's a good athlete but not a great athlete, and that isn't helped by the fact that his wingspan is reportedly 6-foot-2.5. He's not great at beating defenders off the dribble in the halfcourt, which is a problem for an NBA point guard. He's a good shooter but he's not a great shooter. He's a high-level passer but he's not Trae Young or Luka Doncic. He tries defensively but he just doesn't have the physical tools to be a lockdown defender. I'm just not sure what he does that truly sets him apart, and the fact that he was the leader of an Arizona team that kept losing games they shouldn't lose is concerning."
Remember, the author of that paragraph projects Mannion as a higher pick than most. Even Dauster's rationale for slotting him 14th is underwhelming, as it cites a relatively high floor because of his basketball IQ, ability to make shots and his capability in the pick-and-roll.
Those aren't great selling points for the lottery, even in a less-than-great draft. Given all the questions with Mannion's physical tools, it wouldn't be at all shocking if he lasts until the tail end of the opening round.
Nico Mannion, PG, Arizona
A recent scan of the mock draft universe found that Nico Mannion's draft range stretches from No. 10 to No. 30.
NBC Sports' Rob Dauster came in on the higher end, projecting the 19-year-old to go 14th overall, but the subsequent write-up was far from flattering:
"My concern with drafting him this high is that he doesn't really have an NBA skill. He's a good athlete but not a great athlete, and that isn't helped by the fact that his wingspan is reportedly 6-foot-2.5. He's not great at beating defenders off the dribble in the halfcourt, which is a problem for an NBA point guard. He's a good shooter but he's not a great shooter. He's a high-level passer but he's not Trae Young or Luka Doncic. He tries defensively but he just doesn't have the physical tools to be a lockdown defender. I'm just not sure what he does that truly sets him apart, and the fact that he was the leader of an Arizona team that kept losing games they shouldn't lose is concerning."
Remember, the author of that paragraph projects Mannion as a higher pick than most. Even Dauster's rationale for slotting him 14th is underwhelming, as it cites a relatively high floor because of his basketball IQ, ability to make shots and his capability in the pick-and-roll.
Those aren't great selling points for the lottery, even in a less-than-great draft. Given all the questions with Mannion's physical tools, it wouldn't be at all shocking if he lasts until the tail end of the opening round.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Dauster’s assessment is pretty devastating for Nico. It’s also spot-on.
Re: Nico Mannion
except hes not a good shooter
-
- Posts: 1736
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:01 pm
- Reputation: 341
Re: Nico Mannion
This draft class is pretty deep with PG's, based on the eye test there are more than 10 PG's I would take before taking a risk with Nico. I would think it is more likely than not that he falls into the second round. I am not an NBA GM though so maybe there is something that I am missing.
- Alieberman
- Posts: 13841
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 11:50 am
- Reputation: 2885
- Location: I can't find my pants
Re: Nico Mannion
I was going to say that was a brutally accurate write-up except I wouldn't even call him a good shooter.97cats wrote:except hes not a good shooter
That write up describes a 2nd rounder.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Think the most devastating line in that whole thing is, "he doesn't really have an NBA skill." Oh yeah? But he's still going to play for an NBA team?
Re: Nico Mannion
just like so many others before him and after him, he needed an additional summer and collegian year to hone his obvious skills and improve his strength and fitness.
its not that difficult
its not that difficult
- Merkin
- Posts: 43386
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1581
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: Nico Mannion
Nico was a fantastic shooter the first 8 home games v. The Sisters of Mary type teams. Probably close to 50% 3 point shots.
It wasn't until he faced real teams that we realized that he was not a great shooter.
Wake Forest 0-3.
Baylor 1-5.
Gonzaga 1-10.
It wasn't until he faced real teams that we realized that he was not a great shooter.
Wake Forest 0-3.
Baylor 1-5.
Gonzaga 1-10.
Re: Nico Mannion
So why leave? Who is telling him he's ready? Is GLeague money that appealing or did he just not want to be at AZ for another season
Re: Nico Mannion
I assume leaving for the NBA draft after this season was the plan regardless of how it turned out. While the OAD rule is an NBA rule designed to reduce the number of draft busts, it also can benefit players who THINK they are ready right after HS but aren't (or like in Nico's case, STILL not ready after their freshman season).Jefe wrote:So why leave? Who is telling him he's ready? Is GLeague money that appealing or did he just not want to be at AZ for another season
Last edited by CatMG on Wed Apr 29, 2020 5:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Longhorned
- Posts: 14758
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 1:04 pm
- Reputation: 975
- Location: In a guayabera at The Sands Club, Arizona Stadium
Re: Nico Mannion
He's a misevaluation: a one-in-done by declaration rather than ability. Bad for him, and bad for the college program that took him. He needs at least three years in college, probably four. The G-League can be great for development, but not if you're not ready for it.
Re: Nico Mannion
So, what's everyone's thoughts on Nico's shooting ability?
Re: Nico Mannion
He has a lot of potential....azgreg wrote:So, what's everyone's thoughts on Nico's shooting ability?
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
I was waiting for someone to put it this bluntly, and you're absolutely, LH.Longhorned wrote:He's a misevaluation: a one-in-done by declaration rather than ability. Bad for him, and bad for the college program that took him. He needs at least three years in college, probably four. The G-League can be great for development, but not if you're not ready for it.
Misevaluated as a HS player. The guy isn't a stiff, obviously, but clearly there were mistakes made with his scouting report. Now that we've seen him play against top level competition, and have seen how mightily he struggled, I think we can now say that the guy was a pretty serious disappointment, given the level of hype and expectations surrounding him for the past couple years.
Makes you wonder, doesn't it? How was it that TJ McConnell went almost unnoticed as a HS player, landing at a small school in Pittsburgh, even after averaging 34 PPG and 9APG as a senior? TJ is easily among the most important players Miller's ever recruited, and we didn't even know his name till he was a sophomore in college. Compare that to the Nico Mannions and the Daishen Nixes of the world. It goes to show how much is at stake in recruiting. If you get it wrong, or just get burned by a guy who reneges on a commitment, it's hard to recover quickly.
- Chicat
- Posts: 46634
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 12:19 pm
- Reputation: 3978
- Location: Your mother's basement
Re: Nico Mannion
We eat our own better than anyone else.
He’s going to be representing Arizona in the pros. For that reason above all others, I wish him luck. All this postscript trashing of the kid is useless in my opinion. But do what we do I guess...
He’s going to be representing Arizona in the pros. For that reason above all others, I wish him luck. All this postscript trashing of the kid is useless in my opinion. But do what we do I guess...
Of the 12 coaches, Rush picked the one whose fans have the deepest passion, the longest memories, the greatest lung capacity and … did I mention deep passion?
- dovecanyoncat
- Posts: 16750
- Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 12:16 pm
- Reputation: 2144
- Location: Old Farts and Golf Carts
Re: Nico Mannion
He was one of our best 3 pt shooters in practice, so the G-league has that going for him..pc in NM wrote:He has a lot of potential....azgreg wrote:So, what's everyone's thoughts on Nico's shooting ability?
“Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition …There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.”
~ Wilhoit's Law
~ Wilhoit's Law
- Merkin
- Posts: 43386
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 10:31 am
- Reputation: 1581
- Location: UA basketball smells like....victory
Re: Nico Mannion
I remember when it was 4 future NBA players on the UA team plus this slow white mid major guy named TJ. It wasn't until Lute Olson came out and said during TJ's redshirt season that he was the best player on the team. Guess Lute could still evaluate talent then, although he certainly had his share of misses.Beachcat97 wrote:I was waiting for someone to put it this bluntly, and you're absolutely, LH.Longhorned wrote:He's a misevaluation: a one-in-done by declaration rather than ability. Bad for him, and bad for the college program that took him. He needs at least three years in college, probably four. The G-League can be great for development, but not if you're not ready for it.
Misevaluated as a HS player. The guy isn't a stiff, obviously, but clearly there were mistakes made with his scouting report. Now that we've seen him play against top level competition, and have seen how mightily he struggled, I think we can now say that the guy was a pretty serious disappointment, given the level of hype and expectations surrounding him for the past couple years.
Makes you wonder, doesn't it? How was it that TJ McConnell went almost unnoticed as a HS player, landing at a small school in Pittsburgh, even after averaging 34 PPG and 9APG as a senior? TJ is easily among the most important players Miller's ever recruited, and we didn't even know his name till he was a sophomore in college. Compare that to the Nico Mannions and the Daishen Nixes of the world. It goes to show how much is at stake in recruiting. If you get it wrong, or just get burned by a guy who reneges on a commitment, it's hard to recover quickly.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
He's easily the best PG of the Miller era and had us knocking on the door of the FF twice. Fucking Wisconsin.Merkin wrote:I remember when it was 4 future NBA players on the UA team plus this slow white mid major guy named TJ. It wasn't until Lute Olson came out and said during TJ's redshirt season that he was the best player on the team. Guess Lute could still evaluate talent then, although he certainly had his share of misses.Beachcat97 wrote:I was waiting for someone to put it this bluntly, and you're absolutely, LH.Longhorned wrote:He's a misevaluation: a one-in-done by declaration rather than ability. Bad for him, and bad for the college program that took him. He needs at least three years in college, probably four. The G-League can be great for development, but not if you're not ready for it.
Misevaluated as a HS player. The guy isn't a stiff, obviously, but clearly there were mistakes made with his scouting report. Now that we've seen him play against top level competition, and have seen how mightily he struggled, I think we can now say that the guy was a pretty serious disappointment, given the level of hype and expectations surrounding him for the past couple years.
Makes you wonder, doesn't it? How was it that TJ McConnell went almost unnoticed as a HS player, landing at a small school in Pittsburgh, even after averaging 34 PPG and 9APG as a senior? TJ is easily among the most important players Miller's ever recruited, and we didn't even know his name till he was a sophomore in college. Compare that to the Nico Mannions and the Daishen Nixes of the world. It goes to show how much is at stake in recruiting. If you get it wrong, or just get burned by a guy who reneges on a commitment, it's hard to recover quickly.
Last edited by Beachcat97 on Wed Apr 29, 2020 9:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Nico Mannion
Except for having played here, what do you expect him to actually do to “represent” the U of A?Chicat wrote:We eat our own better than anyone else.
He’s going to be representing Arizona in the pros. For that reason above all others, I wish him luck. All this postscript trashing of the kid is useless in my opinion. But do what we do I guess...
“If you have the choice between humble and cocky, go with cocky. There's always time to be humble later, once you've been proven horrendously, irrevocably wrong.”
― Kinky Friedman
― Kinky Friedman
-
- Posts: 3490
- Joined: Sat Sep 23, 2017 3:25 pm
- Reputation: 340
Re: Nico Mannion
I feel like as competition got stronger he had problems getting good looks and settled for those really long 3s.
He could get to the rim but had trouble scoring. He relied on that floater for whatever reason. At times it seemed like he couldn’t create the space to get a layup laid up.
He could get to the rim but had trouble scoring. He relied on that floater for whatever reason. At times it seemed like he couldn’t create the space to get a layup laid up.
Re: Nico Mannion
I’d say Nico Mannion was better his freshman year than TJ McConnell and Peyton Pritchard. Why is anyone comparing Nico as a freshman to McConnell as a senior or Pritchard as a senior?
The travesty IMO is than Nico is believing the hype and was convinced by others to go pro early: either he’s a top 10 pick and should leave OR he was highly rated and now his stock is slipping and he should still leave early before he dips any lower. That’s a sucker bet.
Nico is like a stock in a Bear market that is going to rebound. Why sell low? If he were to follow the same path and stay in school like McConnell and Pritchard, he’d be better than both by his senior season. He needs time, just as they did.
The travesty IMO is than Nico is believing the hype and was convinced by others to go pro early: either he’s a top 10 pick and should leave OR he was highly rated and now his stock is slipping and he should still leave early before he dips any lower. That’s a sucker bet.
Nico is like a stock in a Bear market that is going to rebound. Why sell low? If he were to follow the same path and stay in school like McConnell and Pritchard, he’d be better than both by his senior season. He needs time, just as they did.
- Longhorned
- Posts: 14758
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 1:04 pm
- Reputation: 975
- Location: In a guayabera at The Sands Club, Arizona Stadium
Re: Nico Mannion
There have been a lot of one-and-done's in the Miller era. Three alone this past season. Even Gordon left without having shown much of anything on offense, but at least he was a juggernaut on defense and rebounding. Ayton was truly ready, and gave us a ton to remember him by.
Otherwise, we join a lot of other college basketball programs in having been used. I don't blame the individual players. They're just pawns, and I feel sorry for them. But I do think programs are getting used, and it's at the expense of college basketball, the players, the programs, and the fans.
Otherwise, we join a lot of other college basketball programs in having been used. I don't blame the individual players. They're just pawns, and I feel sorry for them. But I do think programs are getting used, and it's at the expense of college basketball, the players, the programs, and the fans.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Yes.Longhorned wrote: But I do think programs are getting used, and it's at the expense of college basketball, the players, the programs, and the fans.
Re: Nico Mannion
guilty - however, my opinion reflects the long term prospects of the player - id like to think without bias or judgement but.....Chicat wrote:We eat our own better than anyone else.
He’s going to be representing Arizona in the pros. For that reason above all others, I wish him luck. All this postscript trashing of the kid is useless in my opinion. But do what we do I guess...
in this case, regarding Mannion, my comment(s) were and always have been directed at him needing, and ultimately staying, an additional year or two to maximize his value and long term production on the floor as a professional.
by my eye, and from the numbers, hes not a one year college player candidate if his goal is to be a 10year+ NBA veteran.
-
- Posts: 8595
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 8:20 pm
- Reputation: 470
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: Nico Mannion
Better freshmen than Mannion have stayed in school longer than a year. Trier and Budinger come to mind.
Re: Nico Mannion
you ever seen Dennis Rodman as a freshman in college? what about Scottie Pippen? how bout Kawhi Leonard? or Alex Caruso? Jameer Nelson?
you want Arizona? how bout Channing Frye? or Luke Walton? TJ McConnell? Steve Kerr? Damon Stoudamire?
the lists are infinite - a small fraction of players are ready at 18/19years old to make the jump to the NBA and are better served by entering at 20/21/22/23 years of age.
like i said, its not difficult to make a plan, but ego is a crazy thing...
you want Arizona? how bout Channing Frye? or Luke Walton? TJ McConnell? Steve Kerr? Damon Stoudamire?
the lists are infinite - a small fraction of players are ready at 18/19years old to make the jump to the NBA and are better served by entering at 20/21/22/23 years of age.
like i said, its not difficult to make a plan, but ego is a crazy thing...
-
- Posts: 568
- Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2014 10:57 pm
- Reputation: 1
Re: Nico Mannion
Some players just leave too late. Terrance Morris was once considered the #1 draft pick. Each year he stayed in college, his draft stock plummeted. Right up to when he went undrafted.
Other players go to early. One ankle turn, and gone. Forgotten. See Nick Johnson.
Jarrett got to stick in the league for a few games. Ashley went undrafted. How would it have turned out if was Ashley (the better player) who left, and Grant stayed?
These guys have hard decisions. One wrong guess...
Other players go to early. One ankle turn, and gone. Forgotten. See Nick Johnson.
Jarrett got to stick in the league for a few games. Ashley went undrafted. How would it have turned out if was Ashley (the better player) who left, and Grant stayed?
These guys have hard decisions. One wrong guess...
formerly, UA Direct, mtzwami, SnowCat, MontanaCat. should cover every forum I've been on in the last 19 years.
Re: Nico Mannion
I don’t know how you could argue someone is potentially staying too long when they’re borderline projected in the late 1st round. If Mannion was a clear top 10 or even top 20 pick in a relatively weak draft then it would be understandable to leave. He’s clearly not and is leaving anyway, which makes zero sense especially since he’s only a freshman. It’s clear he has a lot of upside and potential but needs at least one or even two more years. It’s like Pritchard leaving after his sophomore year. It’s clear there’s talent but you need to see a lot more: like a whole season more.BigSkyCatinMT wrote:Some players just leave too late. Terrance Morris was once considered the #1 draft pick. Each year he stayed in college, his draft stock plummeted. Right up to when he went undrafted.
Other players go to early. One ankle turn, and gone. Forgotten. See Nick Johnson.
Jarrett got to stick in the league for a few games. Ashley went undrafted. How would it have turned out if was Ashley (the better player) who left, and Grant stayed?
These guys have hard decisions. One wrong guess...
It’s not hating on a player to say he shstay. Nico could really blossom after a few more years. It’s not unread to those could be a top 5 pick in 3 years. If I’m a GM, why would waste a pick knowing he won’t help my team for 3 years and then he’ll be a free agent anyway ?
- Longhorned
- Posts: 14758
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2014 1:04 pm
- Reputation: 975
- Location: In a guayabera at The Sands Club, Arizona Stadium
Re: Nico Mannion
Ego answers to irrational voices. There are many very smart people in the NBA and college basketball. Dean Smith supported Walt Davis, the best Tar Heel before Jordan, when he went to the NBA after three years at UNC. Later, Smith nudged Jordan to leave after three years. It's not that kind of voice high school players are listening to when they agree they're going to be a one-and-done. I seriously doubt Sean Miller urged Nico to limit college to a year. He just had to accept it as a precondition he'd have never agreed with.97cats wrote:you ever seen Dennis Rodman as a freshman in college? what about Scottie Pippen? how bout Kawhi Leonard? or Alex Caruso? Jameer Nelson?
you want Arizona? how bout Channing Frye? or Luke Walton? TJ McConnell? Steve Kerr? Damon Stoudamire?
the lists are infinite - a small fraction of players are ready at 18/19years old to make the jump to the NBA and are better served by entering at 20/21/22/23 years of age.
like i said, its not difficult to make a plan, but ego is a crazy thing...
Re: Nico Mannion
Imagine the meetings he is having with his Agent. You got me in the 2nd round now?!
Re: Nico Mannion
This looks like the situation. Sure , you can plan for one year in college with the expectation to go early. But why make that hard commitment when you don’t have to? Why not leave the door open for the possibility of multiple years in college? It’s funny how people will say he slipped to the second round. Nonsense. He played really good as a freshman. He didn’t dominate. Who’s to say the pre-season predictions were accurate? Players become victims of the preseason hype.Longhorned wrote:Ego answers to irrational voices. There are many very smart people in the NBA and college basketball. Dean Smith supported Walt Davis, the best Tar Heel before Jordan, when he went to the NBA after three years at UNC. Later, Smith nudged Jordan to leave after three years. It's not that kind of voice high school players are listening to when they agree they're going to be a one-and-done. I seriously doubt Sean Miller urged Nico to limit college to a year. He just had to accept it as a precondition he'd have never agreed with.97cats wrote:you ever seen Dennis Rodman as a freshman in college? what about Scottie Pippen? how bout Kawhi Leonard? or Alex Caruso? Jameer Nelson?
you want Arizona? how bout Channing Frye? or Luke Walton? TJ McConnell? Steve Kerr? Damon Stoudamire?
the lists are infinite - a small fraction of players are ready at 18/19years old to make the jump to the NBA and are better served by entering at 20/21/22/23 years of age.
like i said, its not difficult to make a plan, but ego is a crazy thing...