ASUCatfan... That comment was not directed at you - I do not remember all the vocal detractors but there were plenty of people who tore the kid apart. Every UA team has seemed to have its whipping boy(s)... From memory Fogg, Mayes, and York have gotten the worst of it during the Miller era.ASUCatFan wrote:Harvey Specter wrote:Exactly... Lots of selective memories being utilized to justify previous positions.thenewazcats wrote:York was one of the few players who didn't stall the ball two seasons ago. His assist/TO ratio last year was elite. At one point late in the season, he had yet to turn over the ball more than once in a game. So the knock against his passing is unfounded.
I never publicly stated a previous opinion. His numbers may have been good, but he threw at least one lazy long pass per game which resulted in a turnover. Sometimes more. I was giving the kids props for working on that. I think he's been solid for the past month or so in that regard.
I'm related to a D1 Athlete playing a high profile sport and a major conference school. I don't go online and criticize players when they're struggling because I know how that feels as a family member. That said, I stand by my assertion that York was prone to throwing lazy passes and that he has obviously worked hard to fix the problem.
I think Fogg was unfairly hammered for a kid with a limited upside who did the most with what he had... I thought Mayes was turrible.... And have always thought York could be a really good player who has taken longer than any of us would like to reach his potential; he also unfairly carrier the "horrible defender" label for longer than it was deserved. I've also liked the way the kid has handled himself since he has been here.
The only 2 Miller players who have ever deserved the hate that the 3 whipping boys have were Josiah and Sidiki - for non BB related reasons.