Merkin wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 10:18 pm
Grohl's legacy is already cemented in rock and roll history. Not sure why he even cares.
I couldn't name one Taylor Swift song, but you do 152 shows on tour and see if you don't need a little help on backing after doing all that dancing.
Every TV show that had music was lip synced. Every Super Bowl half time show is lip synced.
I remember a few years ago Roger Waters lost his voice, and accidentally left his mic on when singing that song along with the prerecorded version.
The Beatles never lip synced unless it was one of their videos they made lots of videos. They weren't thought of as "videos" back in the '60s ...
One thing you should know is that Ed Sullivan ran a live show. He had a great Orchestra and Orchestra conductor. It didn't matter if you were from a Broadway show, an opera singer, a legitimate popular singer like Barbra Streisand or a rock and roll group like the Dave Clark Five:
Everybody sang with the orchestra or with a group. Performances were live there was no lip-synching on The Ed Sullivan Show; it was a class Prime Time show.
Shows like Dick Clark's American Bandstand which were not primetime more often liked lip-syncing. Variety shows that were on Primetime had a choice, but the upscale ones had live performances.
Ed Sullivan demanded that everyone do a run-through live and if their song was too long the orchestra or the individual musicians had to cut it.
It is well known that he would ask questionable rock groups to change their lyrics Just for his show because it was a family show.
The Stones changed their lyrics but
the Doors agreed to do it and didn't. So Jim Morrison and The Doors were banned from the show.
Sullivan didn't invite performers to his Live program who could not produce a live performance.
But he would allow performers to videotape a live performance from another country or venue when they couldn't come to the show in person. The Beatles and the Dave Clark Five did that a number of times.