Re: Best/Worst analysts/commentators/announcers
Posted: Mon Dec 11, 2017 9:00 am
A co-op community for Arizona Fans
http://beardownwildcats.com/
People love Romo. Madden, just no. Gus Johnson is the most overrated thing in sports. Raftery and Walton are the best in cbb.Pop McKale wrote:Can't listen to many of these dudes anymore. Was just having a fun discussion with a buddy at lunch the other day about football announcers, Tony Romo, etc. and for my money, it didn't get much better than the early 1980's on NBC for the NFL and college basketball. Enberg/Olsen and Enberg/McGuire, Charlie Jones, Don Criqui, et al. Summerall/Madden was an iconic pairing for the NFL on CBS/FOX but nothing's really come close since that era for me.
These days for hoops, give me Gus Johnson and Bill Raftery and I'm set.
Exactly. Creighton playing St. John's on a frigid Nebraska night in January seems like it's THE place to be.UALoco wrote:I love listening to a game Gus is calling, when he's calling, it sounds like the most important game of the year.
When Raftery yells man to man, I want to punch the TV.SunnyAZ wrote:People love Romo. Madden, just no. Gus Johnson is the most overrated thing in sports. Raftery and Walton are the best in cbb.Pop McKale wrote:Can't listen to many of these dudes anymore. Was just having a fun discussion with a buddy at lunch the other day about football announcers, Tony Romo, etc. and for my money, it didn't get much better than the early 1980's on NBC for the NFL and college basketball. Enberg/Olsen and Enberg/McGuire, Charlie Jones, Don Criqui, et al. Summerall/Madden was an iconic pairing for the NFL on CBS/FOX but nothing's really come close since that era for me.
These days for hoops, give me Gus Johnson and Bill Raftery and I'm set.
This, all the way.Pop McKale wrote:Can't listen to many of these dudes anymore. Was just having a fun discussion with a buddy at lunch the other day about football announcers, Tony Romo, etc. and for my money, it didn't get much better than the early 1980's on NBC for the NFL and college basketball. Enberg/Olsen and Enberg/McGuire, Charlie Jones, Don Criqui, et al. Summerall/Madden was an iconic pairing for the NFL on CBS/FOX but nothing's really come close since that era for me.
These days for hoops, give me Gus Johnson and Bill Raftery and I'm set.
Agreed....Watching the replay on YouTube now and it’s soooooooo much better than Walton....They talk about the actual game almost all the time....imagine that....Maybe people / fans watch a game to actually watch the frickin’ game!YoDeFoe wrote:I thought the Dave Pasch / Sean Farnham pairing for the Alabama game was excellent.
Yeah, but no reminder which conference is the Conference of Champions. Plus, neither one thanked someone for our lives.Bangkok Wildcat wrote:Agreed....Watching the replay on YouTube now and it’s soooooooo much better than Walton....They talk about the actual game almost all the time....imagine that....Maybe people / fans watch a game to actually watch the frickin’ game!YoDeFoe wrote:I thought the Dave Pasch / Sean Farnham pairing for the Alabama game was excellent.
yeah, that's the point. He is a try hard. He's like a robot that is set on excitement the whole time. Everything isn't that cool dude and I'm watching the game and know it isn't despite your best efforts to make it seem like it. I also don't think he has any interesting takes or insights. To me he comes off as a dude that isn't that interesting but tries to cover it up by trying to make everything sound interesting.UALoco wrote:I love listening to a game Gus is calling, when he's calling, it sounds like the most important game of the year.
I feel like watching a game Walton is doing is the equivalent of watching at a random bar in an unfamiliar city, sitting next to a guy who won’t shut up about the awesome cleanse he just finished up.SunnyAZ wrote:yeah, that's the point. He is a try hard. He's like a robot that is set on excitement the whole time. Everything isn't that cool dude and I'm watching the game and know it isn't despite your best efforts to make it seem like it. I also don't think he has any interesting takes or insights. To me he comes off as a dude that isn't that interesting but tries to cover it up by trying to make everything sound interesting.UALoco wrote:I love listening to a game Gus is calling, when he's calling, it sounds like the most important game of the year.
I like listening to commentators that seem interesting or are having a good time. It doesn't even really have to be about the game cause I'm watching the game, I don't really need you to tell me what's happening. That's why I like Walton calling UA games, he isn't going to tell me anything about UA that I don't already know (unless it's the stuff where he talks to/about their families, which is always cool) so his ramblings are welcome. It doesn't really come off as well if he's calling a random game where I really don't know about either team playing tho, still more enjoyable than most.
Except there's a mute button. I don't mind Walton bc when I feel like it, I listen. When I don't I mute.Chicat wrote:I feel like watching a game Walton is doing is the equivalent of watching at a random bar in an unfamiliar city, sitting next to a guy who won’t shut up about the awesome cleanse he just finished up.SunnyAZ wrote:yeah, that's the point. He is a try hard. He's like a robot that is set on excitement the whole time. Everything isn't that cool dude and I'm watching the game and know it isn't despite your best efforts to make it seem like it. I also don't think he has any interesting takes or insights. To me he comes off as a dude that isn't that interesting but tries to cover it up by trying to make everything sound interesting.UALoco wrote:I love listening to a game Gus is calling, when he's calling, it sounds like the most important game of the year.
I like listening to commentators that seem interesting or are having a good time. It doesn't even really have to be about the game cause I'm watching the game, I don't really need you to tell me what's happening. That's why I like Walton calling UA games, he isn't going to tell me anything about UA that I don't already know (unless it's the stuff where he talks to/about their families, which is always cool) so his ramblings are welcome. It doesn't really come off as well if he's calling a random game where I really don't know about either team playing tho, still more enjoyable than most.
No thank you.
The WWL is just a perpetual hype machine now. I tune in for highlights, then get the hell out as quickly as possible.Postmaster wrote:Not exactly on topic but I just switched to espn2.
Vitale saying the ball brothers leaving UCLA is a great Xmas gift for Alford.
But the funny part is the description of the game is MI and TX: 2 ncaa blue bloods battle on the court.
I would never consider either a blue blood in basketball.
Oh my.Pop McKale wrote:Dick Enberg, RIP. Dammit.
Yeah, but when Arizona's bench stood up to cheer, did it look like they were genuinely happy? We should bring in one of those body language experts from the cable news.SunnyAZ wrote:Usually in a close game the team that is a huge underdog is going to be more excited about it.
Not to get politically but there is a huge difference between attacking one or two people vs attacking half the countryprh wrote:It's insane that ESPN tolerates Goodman and Dakich attacking people on twitter, especially since they've reprimanded other people for lesser things and changed their social media policies.
I'm not sure if you're referring to anything specifically (probably Jemelle), but my "lesser things" wasn't referring to anything politically. I know the policy changes followed political posts but they've taken issue with all sorts of stuff. They even told people not to break stories on social, although that hasn't really held up.PHXCATS wrote:Not to get politically but there is a huge difference between attacking one or two people vs attacking half the countryprh wrote:It's insane that ESPN tolerates Goodman and Dakich attacking people on twitter, especially since they've reprimanded other people for lesser things and changed their social media policies.
I agree that this type of childish behavior or attacks of any kind should not be tolerated. But for ESPN having people make politically comments risks a lot of viewership especially with their current reputation, attacking individuals risks one or two viewers.prh wrote:I'm not sure if you're referring to anything specifically (probably Jemelle), but my "lesser things" wasn't referring to anything politically. I know the policy changes followed political posts but they've taken issue with all sorts of stuff. They even told people not to break stories on social, although that hasn't really held up.PHXCATS wrote:Not to get politically but there is a huge difference between attacking one or two people vs attacking half the countryprh wrote:It's insane that ESPN tolerates Goodman and Dakich attacking people on twitter, especially since they've reprimanded other people for lesser things and changed their social media policies.
But I'd also say that attacking anyone shouldn't be tolerated, whether it's individuals or large populations. Not in general but especially not by ESPN.
If you’re referring to Jemele Hill, she only attacked one person.PHXCATS wrote:Not to get politically but there is a huge difference between attacking one or two people vs attacking half the countryprh wrote:It's insane that ESPN tolerates Goodman and Dakich attacking people on twitter, especially since they've reprimanded other people for lesser things and changed their social media policies.
Completely agreeprh wrote:Moving on, I think we can all agree that Goodman is a poor representative of UA alumni and the UA, and should probably refrain from being childish on Twitter. He falls squarely into the "worst" category of this thread's discussion.
Pretty sure it's @GoodmanESPN. Could be wrong, but I doubt it.Chicat wrote:How do you say “No one gives a shit” in Lithuanian?
I just looked it up. You are absolutely correct.TucsonClip wrote:Pretty sure it's @GoodmanESPN. Could be wrong, but I doubt it.Chicat wrote:How do you say “No one gives a shit” in Lithuanian?
Hysterical, thanks Clip!TucsonClip wrote:Pretty sure it's @GoodmanESPN. Could be wrong, but I doubt it.Chicat wrote:How do you say “No one gives a shit” in Lithuanian?
Or "niekas neduoda šūdas"TucsonClip wrote:Pretty sure it's @GoodmanESPN. Could be wrong, but I doubt it.Chicat wrote:How do you say “No one gives a shit” in Lithuanian?
DittoOlsondogg wrote:PJC having to answer questions about Goodman's tweet is fucking awful. Fuck him and all that he is.