Page 20 of 39

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 11:24 am
by whatisee
Harvey Specter wrote:
whatisee wrote:Current Commits

5 LB's
3 DL
4 Safety's
2 CB's
2 OL
3 ATH
2 WR
2 TE
2 QB's

25 Total

#25 Class on Scout, #29 Scout, #18 Rivals, #31 ESPN for a 25.75 Average

I'm guessing here, but i believe we still have 3 spots to fill
Are any of those 3 committed athletes projected to play RB?

I hope this class finishes ranked where it is currently... that would be positive.
I believe Nathan Tilford is projected as a RB.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 11:28 am
by azcat49
As I understand the rankings, they only rank the top 25 guys in each class so that no star guy won't impact us negatively. Of course if we get a couple of 4 stars that will bump the lower guys and we will look even stronger.

Many programs though will add guys as they are not up yo 25 yet. I think we will end up 30-35 come signing day

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 12:19 pm
by Harvey Specter
azcat49 wrote:As I understand the rankings, they only rank the top 25 guys in each class so that no star guy won't impact us negatively. Of course if we get a couple of 4 stars that will bump the lower guys and we will look even stronger.

Many programs though will add guys as they are not up yo 25 yet. I think we will end up 30-35 come signing day
I think when it is all said & done (additional decommits and additions) we will end up around 35, which is slightly better than where we usually are when we sign 25+ recruits. 2014 was our best, 2015 our worst, and this looks to be in between...

In classes with ~20 so signees, we ended #45.

In each full recruiting season und RR, here is where we finished according to Rivals:
2013: #37 with 25 recruits (two 4* and four high 3*)
2014: #28 with 28 recruits (six 4* and four high 3*)
2015: #41 with 25 recruits (zero 4* and four high 3*)
2016: #45 with 20 recruits (two 4* and five high 3*)
2017: #TBD with 28? recruits (three 4* and five high 3*)

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 12:23 pm
by azcat49
So basically same old, same old. Shocking I tell ya

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 1:07 pm
by chiefzona
azcat49 wrote:So basically same old, same old. Shocking I tell ya

All that matters is that they're OKGs.

-Dudek

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 6:32 pm
by chiefzona
MrMeow wrote:
chiefzona wrote:
ASUHATER! wrote:
azgreg wrote:
whatisee wrote:Current Commits

5 LB's
3 DL
4 Safety's
2 CB's
2 OL
3 ATH
2 WR
2 TE
2 QB's

25 Total

#25 Class on Scout, #29 Scout, #18 Rivals, #31 ESPN for a 25.75 Average

I'm guessing here, but i believe we still have 3 spots to fill
Any of those D lineman over 247 lbs?
The 3 DL are listed as 6'3 260, 6'3 285 and 6'3 310

Which really doesn't matter when the Arizona offense is fast-paced. It wears those big guys out faster than the smaller ones and then you need depth and quick subs to offset it.
Chief, why does it matter to our DLs that Arizona's offense is fast paced and "wears those big guys our faster..."?
Hard to recruit big uglies when they know they are sucking wind all practice and in games because the offense is too fast paced and is killing the defense.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 6:46 pm
by azcat49
Curious after the success against ASSU if RR rethink the pace of the offense?

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 6:46 pm
by catinfl
I talked to Schooler a little bit and has a tidbit about Faoliu

http://www.azdesertswarm.com/recruiting ... -mater-dei" target="_blank

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 6:56 pm
by azcat49
Are we going to keep him CATINFL? He is really an important piece to this class

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 11:45 am
by catinfl
azcat49 wrote:Are we going to keep him CATINFL? He 8s really an important piece to this class
USC is keeping tabs on him if they offer I doubt he stays. Right now I'd bet on him at Arizona, but Washington State is coming hard for him.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 12:36 pm
by chiefzona
catinfl wrote:
azcat49 wrote:Are we going to keep him CATINFL? He 8s really an important piece to this class
USC is keeping tabs on him if they offer I doubt he stays. Right now I'd bet on him at Arizona, but Washington State is coming hard for him.

Very anticlimactic in this era. He's raw and needs some work from a good DL coach.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 1:45 pm
by azcat49
Chief, his vids look pretty good and he had some nice stats AND he is a big man. Can Amey develope him or are we short on talent at that coaching position?

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 2:22 pm
by chiefzona
azcat49 wrote:Chief, his vids look pretty good and he had some nice stats AND he is a big man. Can Amey develope him or are we short on talent at that coaching position?

As far as I'm concerned, the jury is not out yet on Amey as far as coaching the position goes. Recruiting-wise....I have some negative thoughts but he is virtually new at it.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 3:46 pm
by azcat49
Well damn, I can't think of a more important recruiting position then D Line. Hopefully it's just his youthfulness and inexperience that gives you doubt and not his recognition of talent to recruit.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sat Dec 31, 2016 5:34 pm
by cordera89
So what did I miss.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2017 3:30 pm
by whatisee
cordera89 wrote:So what did I miss.
Sky is falling. We can't recruit. RR can't coach. Chief thinks he's a genius. The usual

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2017 5:25 pm
by Harvey Specter
whatisee wrote:
cordera89 wrote:So what did I miss.
Sky is falling. We can't recruit. RR can't coach. Chief thinks he's a genius. The usual
The gist of your post is accurate.

The only thing happening is recruiting, it is the same-old, same-old... except that we seem to have more decommits than usual.

This should end up a pretty garden-variety RR recruiting class.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 10:01 am
by CatsbyAZ
Harvey Specter wrote: This should end up a pretty garden-variety RR recruiting class.
Proposing this thread be retitled "2017 garden-variety recruits/commitment thread"

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 2:42 pm
by Harvey Specter
CatsbyAZ wrote:
Harvey Specter wrote: This should end up a pretty garden-variety RR recruiting class.
Proposing this thread be retitled "2017 garden-variety recruits/commitment thread"
... or Same Shit, Different Year.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:59 pm
by catinfl
Adrian Ealy deciding Thursday.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 9:08 am
by gronk4heisman
catinfl wrote:Adrian Ealy deciding Thursday.
Would be a big win for us, I just don't see it happening.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 9:14 am
by Merkin

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 9:44 am
by UALoco
Tilford enrolling early means he can't get poached. At least we can look forward to having a big, and hopefully durable, RB in the backfield. That should open up some passing and running options for whoever ends-up at QB. I know folks are down on the Cats, and rightly so, but having a good back would be very good for us.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 10:45 am
by Woodcat
So with Tilford enrolling early does that mean that he counts against last year, or does he still count against this years class? I was just wondering if this frees up another spot for 2017.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 1:46 pm
by Merkin

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 1:50 pm
by azcat49
Woodcat wrote:So with Tilford enrolling early does that mean that he counts against last year, or does he still count against this years class? I was just wondering if this frees up another spot for 2017.
Yes he will count against last years number if possible as we don't know how many scholorships they might have granted to walk on's but one would think they will back date him to last year. With both BB and NT you could say we have room to sign at least 27 plus that one JUCO guy who will come in mid year and that makes 28

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 1:58 pm
by Harvey Specter
Woodcat wrote:So with Tilford enrolling early does that mean that he counts against last year, or does he still count against this years class? I was just wondering if this frees up another spot for 2017.
I would rather save any spots that go unused for 2017 than just fill the class with warm bodies. At this stage, I am not sure how many legitimate prospects we can add.

There is no benefit to just filling open spots. Get real D1 talent now or wait and get it next year.

PS - Very reassuring that both Tilford and Burmeister appear solid.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 3:18 pm
by azcat49
They have that big OT, Ealy deciding in the next few days. He is legit and can enroll early. He is deciding between LSU, Oklahoma and us. Fingers crossed. Get that kid in

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 6:59 pm
by Irish27
Any chance O'Maury Samuels could commit to the UofA?

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 7:04 pm
by azcat49
Irish27 wrote:Any chance O'Maury Samuels could commit to the UofA?
Michigan commit right now but I know we are trying to get him. Others probably know more

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 8:09 pm
by Harvey Specter
I am really struggling to understand how we could snag some kids late in the game with offers fro OK, LSU, UM, etc...

I would really love to see that happen... it just seems awfully unlikely. When was the last time that happened this late in the cycle?

Tabor I suppose... until he switched.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 8:56 pm
by azcat49
I hear you but McGee works Louisiana hard and I guess this kid wants to play very early.

Samuels is from New Mexico and we might have some advantages in being closer for his family

Still either one would be a shock

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 12:33 am
by ChooChooCat
Well looks like Oregon may flip Burmeister at the final hour. If that happens I suggest we blow up the football board for good as there's zero point in its existence. College football recruiting is the most foul cancer ever created.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 5:39 am
by azcat49
Well he is supposed to start classes Monday and he is the QB of the future and he has a special relationship with Rod Smith. I doubt he flips unless he decides to not enroll early

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 6:26 am
by Merkin
Hopefully he makes a statement soon.


Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 8:40 am
by chiefzona
Always adds to the fun of an already self-induced nightmare.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 9:15 am
by UALoco
Interesting that tweet came from the step dad and not BB. We should just recruit orphans with how many parents seem to sabotage our recruit's commitments to AZ (a la Tabor).

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 9:20 am
by whatisee
UALoco wrote:Interesting that tweet came from the step dad and not BB. We should just recruit orphans with how many parents seem to sabotage our recruit's commitments to AZ (a la Tabor).
Aikili Smith is a former Oregon QB, and not a step dad as far as I know

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 9:43 am
by UALoco
whatisee wrote:
UALoco wrote:Interesting that tweet came from the step dad and not BB. We should just recruit orphans with how many parents seem to sabotage our recruit's commitments to AZ (a la Tabor).
Aikili Smith is a former Oregon QB, and not a step dad as far as I know
ah, I read that wrong..he feels like a proud step-dad.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 9:50 am
by Chicat
UALoco wrote:
whatisee wrote:
UALoco wrote:Interesting that tweet came from the step dad and not BB. We should just recruit orphans with how many parents seem to sabotage our recruit's commitments to AZ (a la Tabor).
Aikili Smith is a former Oregon QB, and not a step dad as far as I know
ah, I read that wrong..he feels like a proud step-dad.
Does that mean he's banging Braxton's mom? That has to work in our favor, right?

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 6:15 pm
by Irish27
azcat49 wrote:Well he is supposed to start classes Monday and he is the QB of the future and he has a special relationship with Rod Smith. I doubt he flips unless he decides to not enroll early
First day of classes starts on Wednesday, the 11th. Will have to wait two extra days.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 6:48 pm
by catinfl
Najee Harris to Michigan= Samuels to Arizona

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 7:08 pm
by ASUHATER!
On the radio this afternoon they said that if Burmeister is in Tucson on Sunday that means he's going to Arizona. He'd be moving in on campus on Sunday.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 7:15 pm
by Harvey Specter
catinfl wrote:Najee Harris to Michigan= Samuels to Arizona
My initial response to this post was that it is wishful thinking... but looking at Samuels other offers - this one does not seem so far-fetched.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 7:29 pm
by azcat49
I think Samuels to AZ is better then 50/50, assuming the Harris kid chooses Michigan

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 7:36 pm
by Merkin

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 7:43 pm
by azgreg
I hate college recruiting.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 11:14 pm
by catgrad97
If Burmeister is a no-show next week, Byrne should take the first offer Texas makes for him and go become AD at a real football school. Rich Rod seems committed to blowing up the whole works before he's either forced to go back to the announcer's booth or flim-flam the next AD in Tucson into a couple more years.

But, and I say this as a passionate alum, the Arizona football program has turned into something clearly undeserving of someone of Greg Byrne's caliber. This isn't a Ced Dempsey situation where he didn't make a high enough offer to Larry Smith...this is one of the best college athletic administrators in the country who should go to where he has all the tools to win a national title, which is his true level of talent.

Arizona football is going to suck him down the drain if he sticks around, as the program is being out-recruited at a sad pace that is just cratering it. Nobody in the big markets takes us seriously enough anymore to put together a Pac-12 contender, and regardless of his level of responsibility for it, RichRod knows it.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 11:37 pm
by Carcassdragger
catgrad97 wrote:If Burmeister is a no-show next week, Byrne should take the first offer Texas makes for him and go become AD at a real football school. Rich Rod seems committed to blowing up the whole works before he's either forced to go back to the announcer's booth or flim-flam the next AD in Tucson into a couple more years.

But, and I say this as a passionate alum, the Arizona football program has turned into something clearly undeserving of someone of Greg Byrne's caliber. This isn't a Ced Dempsey situation where he didn't make a high enough offer to Larry Smith...this is one of the best college athletic administrators in the country who should go to where he has all the tools to win a national title, which is his true level of talent.

Arizona football is going to suck him down the drain if he sticks around, as the program is being out-recruited at a sad pace that is just cratering it. Nobody in the big markets takes us seriously enough anymore to put together a Pac-12 contender, and regardless of his level of responsibility for it, RichRod knows it.
Dude, calm down. Nothings happened yet.

Re: 2017 recruits/commitment thread

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2017 1:32 am
by cordera89
catgrad97 wrote:If Burmeister is a no-show next week, Byrne should take the first offer Texas makes for him and go become AD at a real football school. Rich Rod seems committed to blowing up the whole works before he's either forced to go back to the announcer's booth or flim-flam the next AD in Tucson into a couple more years.

But, and I say this as a passionate alum, the Arizona football program has turned into something clearly undeserving of someone of Greg Byrne's caliber. This isn't a Ced Dempsey situation where he didn't make a high enough offer to Larry Smith...this is one of the best college athletic administrators in the country who should go to where he has all the tools to win a national title, which is his true level of talent.

Arizona football is going to suck him down the drain if he sticks around, as the program is being out-recruited at a sad pace that is just cratering it. Nobody in the big markets takes us seriously enough anymore to put together a Pac-12 contender, and regardless of his level of responsibility for it, RichRod knows it.
Why don't you go coach the team yourself if that what you think.